On the record – May 22



Terry J. Kinworthy, 36, Crothersville, possession of methamphetamine, violation of the Legend Drug Act, possession of paraphernalia, possession of marijuana/hashish, no bond, 5:22 p.m. Monday.

Sabrina Leslie Jensen, 41, Crothersville, possession of methamphetamine, violation of the Legend Drug Act, possession of paraphernalia, possession of marijuana/hashish, no bond, 4:29 p.m. Monday.

Jackson County

Timothy James Gares, 22, Defiance, Ohio, warrant for failure to appear, no bond, 4:58 p.m. Monday.

Larry A. Grubbs, 55, Campbellsburg, sexual misconduct with a minor, no bond, 4:14 p.m. Monday.

Joshua Elvern Garrison, 36, Butlerville, two counts of invasion of privacy, $1,410 bond, 1:26 p.m. Monday.

Bonnie S. Davidson, 49, Seymour, domestic battery, $1,505 bond, 11:19 a.m. Monday.

James Brian Davidson, 53, Seymour, domestic battery, $1,505 bond, 10:54 a.m. Monday.


Donald Christopher Huff, 58, Seymour, escape, no bond, 11:49 a.m. Monday.

Jennings County

Zachary Davis, 25, North Vernon, obstruction of justice, $1,055 bond, 7:20 p.m. Monday.

Ricky West, 19, North Vernon, two bench warrants, no bond, 3:15 p.m. Monday.

Brice Anderson, 55, North Vernon, blood alcohol content 0.15% or greater, $905 bond, 3:12 a.m. Monday.

North Vernon

Robert Kocsis, 43, North Vernon, public intoxication, possession of methamphetamine, $3,155 bond, 8:22 p.m. Monday.

Joshua Hartwell, 35, Versailles, driving while suspended-prior, $605 bond, 4:30 a.m. Monday.


Michael Redkey, 22, North Vernon, bench warrant, $1,155 bond, 7:55 p.m. Monday.


Jackson County

Theft of a chainsaw and other items from the bed of a truck overnight, 6800 block of South County Road 1100W, Medora, 7:29 a.m. Tuesday.

Theft of gasoline from an all-terrain vehicle, 9700 block of North U.S. 31, Seymour, 11:27 p.m. Monday.

Report of a man looking in a female juvenile’s bedroom window, 1600 block of West State Road 58, Seymour, 9:54 p.m. Monday.

Report of people yelling and screaming and a woman asking for an officer, 400 block of Pennsylvania Avenue, Crothersville, 9:35 p.m. Monday.

Several purses found scattered on the road, 1700 block of North County Road 450W, Brownstown, 1:45 p.m. Monday.

Agency assist with the removal of multiple animals, 4500 block of North U.S. 31, Seymour, 10:37 a.m. Monday.

Theft of a new set of Dremel tools and attachments and a Craftsman skill saw, first block of South Jackson Street, Medora, 10:12 a.m. Monday.

Family fight, 3900 block of West County Road 1125N, Seymour, 9:30 a.m. Monday.


Theft of a white 2017 Honda Civic, 400 block of South Walnut Street, 11:17 p.m. Monday.

Reckless driving, Tipton and Myers streets, 10:42 p.m. Monday.

Threats, 800 block of West Oak Street, 9:55 p.m. Monday.

Intoxicated man sleeping in the dining room of a nursing home, 700 block of South Jackson Park Drive, 8:58 p.m. Monday.

Agency assist with the search for a vehicle that left the scene of a wreck, Interstate 65, 7:51 p.m. Monday.

Wanted person, 700 block of South Pine Street, 6:48 p.m. Monday.

Agency assist, 2800 block of Whitney Way, 5:53 p.m. Monday.

Theft from a garage, 500 block of West Fourth Street, 5:22 p.m. Monday.

Property damage wreck involving a car and a van, 1100 block of East Oak Street, 4:48 p.m. Monday.

Sex offense reported at the police station, 205 N. Ewing St., 4:30 p.m. Monday.

Traffic offense, O’Brien and Circle streets, 2:28 p.m. Monday.

Theft, 2700 block of Montgomery Drive, 11:39 a.m. Monday.

Possible overdose, 300 block of Juliann Drive, 11:30 a.m. Monday.

Agency assist with an escape from home detention, 900 block of West Brown Street, 11:03 a.m. Monday.

Property damage wreck, 5800 block of West Tipton Street, 9:09 a.m. Monday.

North Vernon

Drug activity, 2400 block of North State Road 3, 7:52 p.m. Monday. An arrest was made.

Disturbance, 400 block of East Buckeye Street, 7:02 p.m. Monday.

Traffic offense, U.S. 50, 4:15 a.m. Monday. An arrest was made.

Marriage licenses

Madison Rene Meese, 20, and Simon A. McDowell, 32, both of 804 W. Oak St., Seymour, issued May 17.

Robert Donald Nichter II, 61, and Chasidy Ann Dickmeyer, 41, both of 41 Village Circle Ave., Seymour, issued May 17.

Michael Lee Riley, 50, and Tiffany Carol Garner, 41, both of 112 N. Bethany Road, Crothersville, issued May 17.

Francisco Aguilar Avila, 40, and Kimberly Ann Noble, 34, both of 901 E. Brown St., Apt. D, Seymour, issued May 16.

Evan Volodymyr, 23, and Kaitlyn Rain Scott, 20, both of 4449 W. Third St., Freetown, issued May 14.

Kyle Curry, 58, 1072 Governors Lane, Seymour, and Cynthia Smith, 56, 171 Kimberly Ave., Seymour, issued May 14.

Blake Wilson McCrary, 29, and Haileigh Michelle Kilpatrick, 27, both of 4139 N. County Road 650W, Brownstown, issued May 14.

Cody Durham, 31, 219 E. Laurel St., Seymour, and Adale Robinson, 31, 3301 McKinley Ave., Apt. D, Columbus, issued May 13.

Daniel D. Luckey, 64, and Marjorie Campbell, 64, both of 1038 Shawna Court, Seymour, issued May 13.

Claire Tangman, 27, 184 E. County Road 800N, Seymour, and Clayton Thomas, 28, 3315 E. Longview Ave., Apt. 25, Bloomington, issued May 13.


Mark Dwight Mellencamp v. Carol Jane Mellencamp, both of 5180 W. County Road 850N, Freetown, married May 18, 2013, not yet separated, filed May 10.

Susan Kay Daniels, 613 W. Brown St., Seymour, v. Roger Dale Daniels, 12328 E. U.S. 50, Apt. 13, Seymour, married May 23, 2008, separated May 23, 2016, filed May 10.

Brian S. Tormoehlen, 6966 Meredith Drive, Seymour, v. Kristina Amanda Tormoehlen, 304 W. Cardinal Drive, Seymour, married June 14, 2013, separated Aug. 1, 2017, filed May 8.

Mickey R. Simpson v. Rosa M. Simpson, 2602 Church St., Denmark, South Carolina, married Dec. 19, 2017, separated Aug. 31, 2018, filed May 8.

Hillary R. Fisher v. Zebulon A. Fisher, both of 5859 N. Morton St., Norman, married June 28, 2014, not yet separated, filed May 7.

Jennifer Robbins, 1158 Whipporwill Drive, Seymour, v. Timmy Robbins Jr., 544 N. U.S. 31, Seymour, married July 17, 2012, not yet separated, filed May 7.

Brian E. Hempstead Jr., 115 S. O’Brien St., Lot 18, Seymour, v. Yesenia M. Hempstead, 19430 Belleau Wood Drive, Apt. 2, Triangle, Virginia, married Feb. 1, 2013, separated February 2017, filed May 7.

Jolene Renee Mellencamp, 309 Holiday Square Road A5, Seymour, v. Thomas Ronald Mellencamp, 8169 N. County Road 300W, Seymour, married July 3, 2017, separated Jan. 1, 2019, filed May 6.

Amanda Herzner v. Thomas J. Herzner Jr., both of 2750 S. County Road 100E, Brownstown, married April 4, 2002, separated May 2, 2019, filed May 3.

Margarita Navarro Zamora, 831 N. Main St., Brownstown, v. Omar Ivan Zarate, 407 Parkland Ave., Seymour, married Nov. 25, 2011, separated May 11, 2019, filed May 2.

Jolene White, no residential address listed, v. Mark White, 719 Country Manor St., North Vernon, married July 7, 2011, separated Dec. 4, 2018, filed May 1.

Tony Brewer II, 1029 N. County Road 600W, v. Kristen E. Brewer, 2372 N. County Road 450W, Freetown, married July 6, 2017, separated May 1, 2019, filed April 30.

Erin Sitterding, no residential address listed, v. Gregory D. VanWinkle, 837 Phillips Lane, Seymour, married July 12, 2010, not yet separated, filed April 29.

John M. Schrader, 200 E. Ninth St., Apt. 3, Seymour, v. Amney D. Schrader, in care of the Jackson County Jail, 150 E. State Road 250, Brownstown, married Aug. 26, 2016, separated Dec. 16, 2018, filed April 29.

Hannah Brenner, 2131 W. State Road 258, Seymour, v. Matthew Brenner, 132 Hillview Trailer Court, Brownstown, married May 12, 2017, separated March 22, 2019, filed April 26.

Miranda Schultheis v. Blake Schultheis, both of 1786 Sam’s Circle, Seymour, married June 29, 2013, no separation date listed, filed April 18.