‘I-65 Killer’ named 30-plus years after 3 killings, Columbus assault

The “I-65 Killer,” who raped and fatally shot three women in Indiana and Kentucky and robbed and sexually assaulted a Columbus woman who survived his knifepoint attack to provide critical evidence, was identified Tuesday after decades as a cold case.

The Indiana State Police said Harry Edward Greenwell, who died in New Albin, Iowa, at age 68 on Jan. 31, 2013, was positively identified through DNA evidence and investigative genealogy as the attacker who also was known as “The Days Inn Killer.” Authorities said Greenwell had a long criminal history before he died from cancer.

The breakthrough was announced at a press conference Tuesday at the Indiana State Police post in Indianapolis. Numerous family members of the victims — Jeanne Gilbert and Mary “Peggy” Gill of Indiana and Vicki Heath of Kentucky — attended the news conference.

“This animal no longer walks the earth,” ISP Superintendent Doug Carter said, telling victims’ family members he wouldn’t mention the killer’s name out of respect for them.

Carter said the scientific and investigative developments in the I-65 Killer case, named as such because the victims were hotel clerks along Interstate 65 in Indiana and Kentucky, would herald a new day in investigations by law enforcement.

While the announcement cleared the Indiana and Kentucky cases, state police said since I-65 goes from Gary in northern Indiana to Mobile, Alabama, investigation continues into murders, rapes, robberies and assaults that have occurred along the I-65 corridor to determine if any of them are connected to Greenwell.

The process of identifying Greenwell as the suspect involved uploading a crime scene DNA profile to one or more genetic genealogy databases in an attempt to identify a criminal offender’s genetic relatives and locate the offender within their family tree. Utilizing this process, a match was made to Greenwell with a close family member with a 99.9999% match.

Carter said the message for criminals is “You might be able to hide for a while, but we’re going to find you, even if you’re not here.”

For family of the victims, Gilbert’s daughter, Kim Gilbert Wright, who is now an attorney, said the news offered an opportunity for healing, though she said those touched by Greenwell’s crimes will heal in different ways.

“I remember her last words,” Gilbert Wright said of her mother. “…‘I love you. I’ll see you tomorrow.’ I didn’t see her that tomorrow, but I see her every day.”

State police said Greenwell targeted women who worked behind the front desks of motels during the overnight shift. The three women whose rapes and murders he is linked to worked as night auditors at motels along I-65 as did his victim in Columbus.

The Columbus victim, who Greenwell attacked on Jan. 2, 1990, provided police a description that ultimately became the face on wanted posters. The suspect’s DNA collected after his attack in Columbus, along with ballistics evidence, also connected him as the suspect behind the killings of Gilbert, Gill and Heath.

Columbus Police Department Lt. Matt Harris, who spoke at the news conference in Indianapolis, said the local victim has remained in touch with investigators over the course of more than 32 years in which the investigation continued.

The Columbus victim was robbed at knifepoint and raped at Days Inn just off of I-65 on Jonathan Moore Pike in Columbus, and the crime closely resembled Greenwell’s fatal attacks. The assault happened nine months after Gilbert and Gill, working at separate motels in northwestern Indiana, had been raped and murdered within hours of each other in March 1989.

The cases remained unsolved until Tuesday, despite the persistence of victims’ family members and law enforcement at the local, state and federal level in seeking justice. After the police sketch based on the Columbus victim’s description appeared in The Republic and newspapers around the state and country, similar crimes ceased.

Trail of terror

Heath, 41, of Elizabethtown, Kentucky, was the I-65 killer’s first victim in February 1987. A guest of the Super 8 motel where she worked awoke to discover the lobby in disarray and what appeared to be evidence of a fight. The phone had been ripped from the wall, and Heath was reported missing.

Police soon found Heath’s body behind a dumpster near the motel. Investigators determined she had been sexually assaulted and shot twice in the head with a .38-caliber handgun.

A little more than two years later and 300 miles north of that crime scene along I-65, Greenwell struck again.

Gill, 24, who worked at Days Inn in Merrillville, also was raped and shot twice in the head, this time with a .22-caliber handgun.

A few hours later and about 50 miles south, Gilbert, 34, who worked at Days Inn in Remington, was assaulted and then shot with the same gun.

Investigators say each case followed a similar pattern: The suspect robbed the motel cash drawer at gunpoint before violently assaulting each victim, then killing them and leaving their bodies outside.

Columbus case

Nine months after the double killings in northwestern Indiana, a white, bearded man described as about 35 to 45 years old, 6 feet tall and weighing about 180 pounds, wearing blue jeans, a plaid flannel shirt and a stocking cap arrived before 5 a.m. at Days Inn in Columbus.

On a freezing morning in January 1990, he stopped in and asked the woman behind the desk where he could get something to eat at that hour. After the woman offered some suggestions, the man left saying he’d return shortly. He came back a few minutes later holding a Styrofoam cup full of coffee and asked for some change for vending machines, according to reporting in The Republic.

“When she opened the cash register, the man threw coffee in her face and jumped across the desk. He drew a 6-inch knife with a brown handle and told her to give him all of the money,” police said at the time.

After assaulting the victim, he led her outside, and she told police she believed he was going to kill her. She walked behind the motel, hearing her attacker’s footsteps behind her, until she fell through a thin layer of ice in a ditch into freezing shallow water.

Her attacker had left.

“The woman continued walking up a hill where she found a house trailer, about one-quarter mile from the motel,” according to the police report. “She pounded on the door and a woman answered. The victim was given shelter. City police were called immediately, about 5:55 a.m.”

The victim was treated and released from the hospital.

Harris and Sgt. Glen Fifield, public information officer for the ISP Lowell District, said evidence the Columbus victim provided was critical in piecing together the details that ultimately led to the positive identification of Greenwell.

She was the only known victim to survive the vicious, brutal attacks of this killer, Fifield said. She also provided a detailed description of the suspect, which was crucial to the investigation, state police said.

Meanwhile, police said the evidence gathered in the investigation of the deaths of Gill, Gilbert and Heath as well as the attack on the Columbus victim is being looked at for possible connections to at least one other cold case. Police said there could be others.

Authorities said the case marked a cooperative approach between police departments in Columbus, Elizabethtown, Kentucky, Merrillville, Jasper County, Indiana State Police and the FBI.

“These cases did not go unsolved all these years because of a lack of investigative inactivity. Investigators continuously tracked leads across the country and did everything they could to identify the person responsible for these crimes,” FBI Indianapolis Special Agent in Charge Herbert J. Stapleton said. “Now, through technological advances and strong, collaborative partnerships, we were able to identify this person and hopefully start to bring closure and healing to the families of Vicki, Peggy and Jeanne as well as the surviving victim.”

ISP officers removed reporters before the scheduled start of the press conference Tuesday to give families of the victims an opportunity to address them privately. Fifield said this would be the families’ only opportunity to do so as a group at the conclusion of the investigation. Family members met privately with law enforcement officers for about 10 minutes before Greenwell was publicly identified.

Legacy of crime 

Here is a timeline of events in the life of Harry Edward Greenwell, identified Tuesday as the I-65 Killer. Greenwell died in 2013.

Jan. 17, 1963: Arrested on charge of armed robbery, Louisville, Kentucky.

April 12, 1963: Convicted, sentenced to two years in reformatory, five years probation.

Feb. 23, 1965: Arrested in Jefferson County, Kentucky, charged with sodomy.

October 1969: Paroled from Kentucky State Penitentiary.

April 28, 1978: Greenwell’s wife died in a house fire in Vernon County, Wisconsin.

Aug. 21, 1980: Greenwell remarried in Henry County, Kentucky.

June 17, 1982: Arrested in Vernon County, Iowa, on burglary charge. Escaped twice, recaptured.

Aug. 10, 1982: Sentenced to Anamosa State Penetentiary, Iowa.

Dec. 5, 1983: Released from Kentucky State Reformatory.

Feb. 21, 1987: Murder of Vicki Heath at Super 8 motel in Elizabethtown, Kentucky.

March 3, 1989: Murder of Margaret Gill at Days Inn in Merrillville and Jeanne Gilbert at Days Inn in Remington.

Jan. 2., 1980: Assault and rape of Days Inn clerk in Columbus.

Oct. 11, 1998: Arrested on drug possession and restraining order violations in Allamakee County, Iowa; case dismissed in November 1998.

January 2013: Greenwell dies of cancer in Iowa.

April 5, 2021: Greenwell identified as I-65 Killer responsible for killing Heath, Gill and Gilbert and assaulting the Columbus victim.

Source: FBI Indianapolis Division